Zubayr ibn al-Awwam: The Disciple of the Prophet

Zubayr ibn al-Awwam was one of the most distinguished companions of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, honored with the title "Hawari" (Disciple) of the Prophet. As one of the earliest converts to Islam and one of the Ten Promised Paradise, Zubayr was known for his exceptional courage in battle and his unwavering loyalty to the Prophet. He was also the Prophet's cousin, being the son of Safiyyah bint Abd al-Muttalib, the Prophet's paternal aunt. Despite his honored status and heroic service, Zubayr's life ended tragically at the Battle of the Camel in 656 CE, where he fought against Ali ibn Abi Talib before withdrawing from the battle and being killed while traveling home. His death marked one of the great tragedies of the First Fitna, the civil war that divided the early Muslim community.

Early Life and Conversion to Islam

Zubayr was born around 594 CE in Mecca into the Banu Asad clan of the Quraysh tribe. His father, al-Awwam ibn Khuwaylid, died when Zubayr was young, and he was raised by his mother, Safiyyah bint Abd al-Muttalib, who was the Prophet Muhammad's aunt. This family connection meant that Zubayr grew up knowing his cousin Muhammad and was familiar with his character and reputation even before the advent of Islam.

Zubayr was one of the very first converts to Islam, accepting the faith when he was only about sixteen years old. According to tradition, he was either the fourth or fifth person to convert, making him one of the earliest Muslims. His early conversion brought severe persecution from his family and tribe. His uncle subjected him to particularly harsh treatment, hanging him upside down and lighting fires beneath him to force him to renounce Islam. Despite this torture, Zubayr refused to abandon his faith, demonstrating the steadfastness that would characterize his entire life.

As one of the earliest Muslims, Zubayr was part of the small, persecuted community that gathered around the Prophet in Mecca. He endured years of harassment, social ostracism, and physical abuse for his faith. This early period of persecution strengthened the bonds between the early Muslims and established Zubayr's reputation for courage and commitment. The Prophet recognized Zubayr's exceptional qualities and gave him the special title "Hawari" (Disciple), comparing him to the disciples of Jesus. This title reflected the close relationship between Zubayr and the Prophet and Zubayr's role as one of the Prophet's most trusted companions.

The Hijra and Military Service

When the Muslims emigrated to Medina in 622 CE, Zubayr was among those who made the journey. In Medina, the Muslim community could practice their faith openly and began to establish an Islamic society. Zubayr quickly became one of the Prophet's most important military commanders, participating in virtually every major battle and expedition during the Prophet's lifetime.

Zubayr fought at the Battle of Badr in 624 CE, the first major military engagement between the Muslims and the Meccans. At Badr, Zubayr distinguished himself through his bravery, and the Muslims' unexpected victory established their credibility as a military force. Zubayr's courage at Badr was remembered throughout his life as evidence of his commitment to Islam and his willingness to risk his life for the faith.

At the Battle of Uhud in 625 CE, Zubayr again demonstrated exceptional bravery. When the Muslim army was thrown into confusion by a surprise cavalry attack, Zubayr was one of the few companions who remained steadfast, fighting to protect the Prophet. His actions at Uhud, along with those of Talha ibn Ubaydullah and a few others, prevented the Meccans from killing or capturing the Prophet and allowed the Muslim army to regroup and survive the defeat.

Zubayr participated in the Battle of the Trench in 627 CE, where the Muslims defended Medina against a large coalition of Meccan and allied forces. He also participated in the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah negotiations in 628 CE and was present at the conquest of Mecca in 630 CE, when the Prophet entered his hometown in triumph and the Meccans accepted Islam. Throughout these campaigns, Zubayr established himself as one of the most capable and courageous Muslim warriors, earning the Prophet's trust and the respect of the Muslim community.

One of the Ten Promised Paradise

Zubayr was one of the ten companions whom the Prophet specifically named as being promised Paradise. This honor, known as al-'Ashara al-Mubashshara, was the highest recognition a companion could receive. The Prophet's declaration that Zubayr was promised Paradise was based on his early conversion, his steadfastness under persecution, his bravery in battle, and his overall character and devotion to Islam.

Being named among the Ten Promised Paradise gave Zubayr immense prestige in the Muslim community. It was a divine guarantee of salvation and a recognition of exceptional faith and service. This honor meant that regardless of any later controversies or mistakes, Zubayr's fundamental righteousness and his place in Paradise were assured by the Prophet's own words. In Islamic tradition, the Ten Promised Paradise are revered as models of faith and righteousness, and their status is seen as a divine confirmation of their virtue.

The title "Hawari" (Disciple) that the Prophet gave to Zubayr further emphasized his special status. Just as Jesus had his disciples who were his closest followers and supporters, the Prophet had Zubayr as his disciple, a companion of exceptional loyalty and devotion. This title reflected the close personal relationship between Zubayr and the Prophet and Zubayr's role as one of the Prophet's most trusted companions.

Role During the Rashidun Caliphate

After the Prophet's death in 632 CE, Zubayr played an important role in the early Muslim community. He was present at the Saqifah meeting where Abu Bakr was chosen as the first caliph, and he pledged his allegiance to Abu Bakr. During Abu Bakr's brief caliphate (632-634 CE), Zubayr continued to serve the Muslim community, participating in military campaigns against the apostasy movements that threatened the unity of the Muslim state.

Under Umar ibn al-Khattab's caliphate (634-644 CE), Zubayr participated in the great Islamic conquests that expanded Muslim territory into Syria, Iraq, Egypt, and Persia. He fought at the Battle of Yarmouk in 636 CE, one of the most decisive battles in Islamic history, where the Muslims defeated the Byzantine army and secured control of Syria. Zubayr's military skills and courage were crucial to these conquests, and he earned a reputation as one of the most capable Muslim commanders.

When Umar was assassinated in 644 CE, he designated a council of six companions to choose his successor. Zubayr was one of these six, along with Uthman, Ali, Talha, Sa'd ibn Abi Waqqas, and Abd al-Rahman ibn Awf. This selection demonstrated Zubayr's high standing in the community and his recognition as one of the most qualified potential leaders. The council ultimately chose Uthman ibn Affan as the third caliph, and Zubayr pledged his allegiance to him.

Opposition to Uthman and the Crisis

During Uthman's caliphate (644-656 CE), tensions developed within the Muslim community over various policies and appointments. Uthman faced criticism for favoring his Umayyad relatives in appointments, for his handling of conquered territories, and for various administrative decisions. As opposition to Uthman grew, some of the senior companions, including Zubayr, became increasingly critical of the caliph's policies.

The exact nature and extent of Zubayr's opposition to Uthman is debated by historians. Some sources suggest that Zubayr was among the leaders of the opposition, actively criticizing Uthman's policies and supporting demands for reform. Other sources suggest that while Zubayr had concerns about some of Uthman's decisions, he did not actively participate in the opposition movement until the final crisis. What is clear is that by the final years of Uthman's caliphate, Zubayr was among those who believed that reforms were necessary.

In 656 CE, opposition to Uthman culminated in a siege of his house in Medina by rebels from Egypt, Iraq, and other provinces. The role of senior companions like Zubayr during this crisis is controversial. Some accounts suggest that Zubayr and others could have done more to protect Uthman but chose not to intervene. Other accounts suggest that they attempted to mediate but were unable to prevent the tragedy. When rebels finally broke into Uthman's house and killed him while he was reading the Qur'an, the Muslim community was shocked and divided.

The Battle of the Camel

After Uthman's assassination, Ali ibn Abi Talib was chosen as the fourth caliph. However, his caliphate was immediately contested. Zubayr, along with Talha ibn Ubaydullah and Aisha bint Abu Bakr (the Prophet's widow), demanded that Ali immediately punish those responsible for Uthman's murder. Ali argued that he needed to consolidate his authority before he could pursue Uthman's killers, many of whom were in his own army.

Unsatisfied with Ali's response, Zubayr, Talha, and Aisha left Medina and traveled to Basra in Iraq, where they gathered an army to pressure Ali to take action. Their stated goal was not to overthrow Ali but to force him to bring Uthman's killers to justice. Ali marched from Medina with his own army to confront them, and the two sides met near Basra in December 656 CE.

According to the accounts, both sides initially sought to avoid battle, and negotiations were attempted. Zubayr and Ali met privately before the battle, and Ali reminded Zubayr of the Prophet's words and their long friendship. According to tradition, Ali asked Zubayr: "Do you remember when the Prophet said to you that you would fight against me while you were in the wrong?" Zubayr reportedly replied that he did remember and that he would not have come if he had recalled this earlier. Moved by this conversation, Zubayr decided to withdraw from the battle.

However, those who had participated in Uthman's murder, fearing that they would be punished if the two sides reconciled, provoked fighting between the armies. The Battle of the Camel began despite the attempts at reconciliation. Zubayr, having decided to withdraw, left the battlefield and began traveling back toward Medina. However, he was pursued and killed by a man named Amr ibn Jurmuz, who apparently did not know who Zubayr was or believed he was acting righteously by killing a rebel against Ali.

When Ali learned of Zubayr's death, he was deeply grieved. According to tradition, Ali said: "Give the killer of the son of Safiyyah the tidings of Hell." When Amr ibn Jurmuz brought Zubayr's sword to Ali, expecting a reward, Ali refused to accept it and condemned the killing. The Prophet's sword, which Zubayr had carried, was returned to Zubayr's family. Zubayr died at the age of about 62, one of the Ten Promised Paradise killed in the first Muslim civil war.

Legacy and Historical Memory

Zubayr's legacy is complex and has been debated throughout Islamic history. On one hand, he is honored as one of the earliest converts to Islam, one of the Ten Promised Paradise, the Prophet's "Disciple," and a hero of numerous battles. His courage, loyalty, and devotion to the Prophet are universally acknowledged. On the other hand, his role in the opposition to Uthman and his participation in the Battle of the Camel have been controversial.

Traditional Sunni scholarship has generally taken a sympathetic view of Zubayr, arguing that he acted with good intentions even if his actions had tragic consequences. The principle of "withholding judgment" on the disputes between the companions has been applied to Zubayr, with scholars arguing that the conflicts of the early civil war were matters of ijtihad (independent reasoning) in which sincere Muslims disagreed about the right course of action. Zubayr's status as one of the Ten Promised Paradise is seen as proof that despite his mistakes, he remained a righteous companion whose place in Paradise was assured.

The tradition that Zubayr withdrew from the Battle of the Camel after being reminded of the Prophet's words has been emphasized by those who wish to present him in a positive light. In this view, Zubayr recognized his error and attempted to correct it by withdrawing from the battle, demonstrating his fundamental righteousness even if he had initially made a mistake. His death while withdrawing is seen as a tragedy rather than as punishment for wrongdoing.

Critics of Zubayr, particularly in Shia tradition, have been less forgiving. They argue that Zubayr's opposition to Uthman contributed to the crisis that led to the caliph's murder, and that his subsequent rebellion against Ali was unjustified and contributed to the fitna that divided the Muslim community. In this view, Zubayr's actions, whatever his intentions, had disastrous consequences for Islamic unity.

Modern historians have attempted to understand Zubayr's actions in their historical context, recognizing the complexity of the political situation after Uthman's assassination and the genuine disagreements about how to respond to the crisis. Zubayr's demand that Uthman's killers be punished was not unreasonable, and his frustration with Ali's delay in taking action was understandable. However, the decision to raise an army and confront Ali militarily had tragic consequences that Zubayr may not have fully anticipated.

Zubayr's withdrawal from the Battle of the Camel, whether motivated by Ali's reminder of the Prophet's words or by his own realization of the wrongness of the conflict, suggests that he recognized his error. His death while withdrawing adds a tragic dimension to his story, as he was killed not in battle but while attempting to leave the conflict. This has led some to view Zubayr's end as particularly tragic—a righteous companion who made a mistake, recognized it, and attempted to correct it, only to be killed by someone who did not understand the situation.

Conclusion

Zubayr ibn al-Awwam's life reflects both the heroism of the early Muslim community and the tragic divisions that emerged after the Prophet's death. As one of the earliest converts to Islam, he endured severe persecution with steadfastness. As the Prophet's "Disciple" and one of the Ten Promised Paradise, he was honored with the highest recognition a companion could receive. As a warrior, he demonstrated exceptional courage in numerous battles, contributing to the survival and expansion of the Muslim community.

Yet Zubayr's life ended in tragedy at the Battle of the Camel, fighting against Ali ibn Abi Talib in the first major civil war in Islamic history. His withdrawal from the battle and his death while traveling home add poignant dimensions to his story, suggesting a man who recognized his error and attempted to correct it but was unable to escape the consequences of the conflict he had helped initiate. Understanding Zubayr requires recognizing both his virtues and his mistakes, his heroism and his tragic end, and the complex political and religious context in which he lived and died. His story reminds us that even the most honored companions were human beings who faced difficult choices and sometimes made decisions with tragic consequences.